The Ryan Samuels Show

Monday–Friday at 9 PM ETMon–Fri 9 PM ET LIVE

The Ryan Samuels Show goes live weeknights at 9 PM ET.

Watch Live

Stephen Miller Takes Over. The Constitution Still Applies.

Stephen Miller Takes Over. The Constitution Still Applies.

President Donald Trump named Stephen Miller White House chief of staff on November 6, succeeding Susie Wiles, according to the official White House announcement. The release calls Miller the 33rd person to hold the job and praises both him and Wiles in the language administrations reserve for their own. Those are the White House’s judgments. They are not independent findings that every policy either of them advanced succeeded. The verified news is the appointment. It does not write a new clause into the Constitution.

Stephen Miller at a lectern during the 2025 CPAC conference.
Stephen Miller speaking at CPAC in National Harbor, Maryland, February 22, 2025. File photo; not a photograph of a new appointment. Credit: Gage Skidmore / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0 (resized only). Source: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Stephen_Miller_(54361384084).jpg | License (CC BY-SA 2.0): https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/2.0/

A trusted ally now sits closer to the president’s calendar. That is not a constitutional amendment. An effective chief of staff can make the government move faster. Whether it moves lawfully is a different question, and the more important one.

The job is consequential because a president’s hours are scarce. The person who organizes the operation, coordinates the priorities, and decides what reaches the desk can shape what happens next. Influence, though, is not a separate grant of power. A memorandum circulating through the West Wing does not become a statute. An instruction from an adviser does not erase an agency’s legal duties or create spending authority Congress never supplied.

Article II tells the president to take care that the laws are faithfully executed. It does not authorize a staffer to decide which restrictions are inconvenient enough to ignore. Article I assigns legislative power to Congress and requires appropriations made by law before money leaves the Treasury. Those clauses do not recede because the new chief of staff has the president’s trust.

Conservatives ought to be able to say both of the following without choking on either one. Electing a president should matter. Winning an election should not dissolve the boundaries of the office. The alternative is to demand an unchecked executive today and pretend the next administration will politely hand the same machinery back tomorrow.

Miller’s promotion puts immigration and the border back at the center of the conversation, themes the White House release returns to again and again. Supporters expect determined execution of Trump’s agenda. That expectation is politically understandable. It is not proof of any particular order about to be signed.

A country can enforce its immigration laws without treating legal process as a favor officials may confer or withhold. Congress writes the statutes. Executive officers carry them out inside the authority those statutes provide. Courts decide disputes about whether a challenged action complies with the law. Immigration proceedings are not carbon copies of criminal trials, and the available procedures vary with a person’s status, location, and circumstances. Claiming everyone holds precisely the same procedural rights would be sloppy. Claiming the government owes nobody any meaningful process would be worse.

The serious standard is not whether an action looks tough on television. It is the law that authorizes the action, the factual determination behind it, the review available, and whether the agency followed the procedure required of it. Those questions protect lawful enforcement from the shortcuts that later unravel it.

The useful test of Miller’s tenure will be documents and decisions, not the volume of the applause that greeted the announcement. Watch the statutory explanations attached to policy changes. Watch whether officials can tell an obligation Congress enacted from a discretionary choice the executive may legitimately reverse. Watch the spending. Bureaucratic enthusiasm does not appropriate money. If the administration wants a larger program, more detention capacity, or a new enforcement push, the legal authority and the funding deserve scrutiny. A patriotic label pasted over the invoice is not a substitute.

There is a Jeffersonian reason to keep this discipline even when you like the official in the job. Liberty depends less on finding permanently trustworthy people than on preventing any person from acquiring permanently unaccountable power. Competence inside limits is an asset. Competence without limits simply makes abuse more efficient.

Readers who want the wider frame can start with the Beginner’s Guide to Constitutional Conservatism. The principle does not change with the nameplate on the West Wing door.

Miller has a demanding new job. Trump has a different manager for his team. Neither man received a constitutional exception. The strongest version of an America First agenda would prove it can deliver under the law, not argue that urgency places it above the law.

An administration can enforce the law without inventing new powers, which is the same line in who controls tariffs and in the reminder that Democrats won Congress, not a blank check.

Sources: White House release, Nov. 6, 2026; U.S. Constitution

The Ryan Samuels Show is live weeknights at 9 PM ET; podcast at pod.link/1652595335

Featured illustration: AI-generated editorial illustration by The Ryan Samuels Show, based on a photo by Gage Skidmore / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0; stylized, recolored and redesigned. Illustration distributed under CC BY-SA 2.0.

Thumbnail source: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Stephen_Miller_(54361384084).jpg | License (CC BY-SA 2.0): https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/2.0/

Filed under:

Get Ryan’s Columns in Your Inbox

Sign up for free and get every new column from The Ryan Samuels Show delivered to your inbox.