Charlotte has asked a judge to toss the wrongful-death suit over Iryna Zarutska’s murder on its light rail, citing governmental immunity and a $1 million cap. A city that sells you the ride owes you more than that.
By Ryan Samuels

Charlotte doesn’t want to pay Iryna Zarutska’s family. On Monday, Nov. 16, the city’s lawyers filed a motion to dismiss in Mecklenburg County Superior Court. Strip away the legal language, and that is all it says.
Iryna was 23. She left Ukraine to escape a war. On the night of Aug. 22, 2025, she was riding home from work. She boarded the LYNX Blue Line at Scaleybark station at about 9:46 p.m. and took a seat in the row in front of DeCarlos Brown Jr. About four minutes later, he stabbed her. She died on that train.
The city doesn’t dispute any of this. Its own filing admits it. Charlotte also admits that Iryna paid her fare, that Brown boarded without showing a ticket, and that no private security guard stood inside that car when he attacked her.
Her uncle, Frank Scott Haskell, had taken the family in when they came to Charlotte. In August, he sued the city and its transit security contractor. Mediation ended in an impasse this month. Now the city wants a judge to dismiss the case with prejudice, which means the family could never file it again.
The city’s lawyers make three arguments. First, governmental immunity: nobody can sue the government over this. Second, the public-duty doctrine: a city owes protection to the public at large, not to any one rider. Third, superseding cause: Brown’s crime, not anything the city did, caused her death. And if any claim survives, the city wants the court to cap its bill at $1 million under state law.
I want to be fair here. Lawyers file motions like this all the time as a first move. No judge has ruled on it, and the family still has to prove its case. But notice what Charlotte chose to argue. The city isn’t saying, “We did everything right, so let a jury see it.” It’s saying no jury should look at all.
That’s where I part ways with Charlotte, and I start from a simple place. Iryna’s right to life didn’t come from the City of Charlotte. It came from God, and it belonged to her long before she ever paid a fare. Jefferson told us that governments exist to secure those rights. That is the whole job. When a city runs the train, sells the fare, and hires the guards, it takes on part of that job for every passenger who steps aboard. When it fails, it should answer for that failure the way any of us would.
Governmental immunity traces back to an old English idea: the king can do no wrong. We fought a revolution over that king, and I see no reason a transit system should inherit his crown. North Carolina’s own constitution points the other way. Article I, Section 18 promises that every person, “for an injury done him in his lands, goods, person, or reputation shall have remedy by due course of law.” A family that lost a daughter on a city train deserves its day in court, not a door slammed shut on a technicality.
And the facts a jury would hear aren’t flattering to the city. I’ll let the state auditor make this case, because these are his findings, not mine. After Iryna’s murder, State Auditor Dave Boliek’s office reviewed the transit system’s security contracts. Under the 2018 contract, the system had roughly 68 to 88 armed security personnel. Under the current one, it has 39. Over the same stretch, the contract’s value climbed from $5.9 million in 2022 to $18.4 million in 2025. With only 39 armed personnel, the auditor said, the system couldn’t put an armed guard on all 48 of its train cars at once.
The auditor found something else. The transit system’s 2022 request for proposals for unarmed security “targeted only” firms that the Charlotte Business Inclusion program had certified. Boliek put it bluntly: “limiting any part of a contract providing citizens with security to only firms that meet a DEI checkbox raises questions as to whether politics has taken priority over public safety.” More money, fewer armed guards, and a box to check. The city denies that any of this caused Iryna’s death, and it has every right to make that argument. I just want twelve citizens to hear it.
They should also hear about the man who killed her. Police had arrested Brown 14 times before. In January 2025, a magistrate released him on a written promise to appear after a misdemeanor charge of misusing 911. That charge carried no more than 45 days, so I won’t pretend one signature explains everything. Still, a man with that record never should have been walking the streets in the first place.
He sits in custody now, where he belongs. He faces a federal charge that carries life in prison or death. A judge found him incompetent to proceed, meaning he can’t stand trial for now, and the court moved a hearing in his state murder case to May 2027.
When I covered this story on my show, the transit system wanted to talk about keeping fare skippers off the train. Oh yeah, because that’ll solve it. Sure, Brown never should have boarded that train. But a missing ticket was never the real problem. The real problem was a man with 14 arrests walking free and a train car with no guard in it.
To its credit, Raleigh acted. Iryna’s Law became law on Oct. 3, 2025. It tightened pretrial release for violent offenders and ended written promises to appear. That fixes the courthouse side of this story. It does nothing for the family that already lost her.
Ken Silva, the investigative reporter who came on my show, told me he obtained the video of the attack and put it out. I’m glad he did. Anyone who watches it sees a young woman sitting quietly with her earbuds in, and sees how fast it ended. I don’t believe anyone who has seen that video thinks the people who run that train owe her family nothing.
Charlotte didn’t hold the knife. I’ll say that plainly. But this government took her fare, controlled the platform, and wrote the security contract. Now it tells a grieving family the law won’t even let them ask questions. That isn’t securing anybody’s rights. That’s protecting itself.
So here’s my ask. Charlotte, drop the immunity shield, let a jury hear the facts, and pay her family.
I covered Iryna’s murder on the show in the episode above, and I’ll stay on this case as the judge rules. Tell me what you think, and watch The Ryan Samuels Show live every weeknight at 9 PM ET.
Listen to The Ryan Samuels Show:
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@RyanFSamuels
Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-ryan-samuels-show/id1652595335
Spotify: The Ryan Samuels Show on Spotify
Rumble: https://rumble.com/c/TheRyanSamuelsShow
Featured image: Iryna Zarutska, in the black cap, rides the LYNX Blue Line minutes before the Aug. 22, 2025, attack. Image: Charlotte Area Transit System surveillance video, via AP. Text added.






