The last uncalled Senate race of the midterms is still unofficial, and more ballots are coming in. The current count already answers the claim that a second Dan Sullivan handed Democrats the seat.
By Ryan Samuels
I’m a Republican, and I have to say something a lot of people in my own party aren’t going to want to hear. Two weeks after the election, Alaska is still counting the last Senate race in the country, and former Rep. Mary Peltola, a Democrat, is ahead of Republican Sen. Dan S. Sullivan. I’ll just call it like it is. The other Dan Sullivan did not steal this seat.
The Alaska Division of Elections put out an unofficial report at 5:13 p.m. Monday, Alaska time, and I went through it because this is the part that either holds up or it doesn’t. Peltola is at 141,637 votes, 49.98 percent, and Sullivan is at 130,162, or 45.93 percent, so she’s up by 11,475. She’s also 52 votes short of a first-round majority, which on this count is 141,689, so in that one narrow way it is still tight, and I want to be honest about that. Then you’ve got a second Republican, Gerald L. Heikes, with 6,020 and Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., the retired Petersburg teacher at the center of this fight, with 4,684, along with 874 write-ins, and all 401 precincts are already in. More mail ballots can still be counted through Wednesday, and the Anchorage Daily News says that’s the last day they’ll tally votes.
If she crosses 50 percent by then, she wins outright, and if she stays just under it, Alaska’s ranked-choice system kicks in and they reallocate the later preferences of the people who backed Heikes and the other Sullivan. The Daily News has already looked at preliminary ballot data and says she’d still come out ahead, though none of this is certified, and certification isn’t expected until Nov. 25. Sullivan’s spokesman, Nate Adams, said Monday the campaign is going to let that process run and won’t comment on individual ballot updates. “Alaskans deserve a complete and accurate count, and we will let that process run its course until every legal vote is counted and certified.” I don’t have a quarrel with that, and I’d rather they wait than start talking before the Division is finished.
And I get why this has people angry, because there really are two Dan Sullivans on that ballot, and I’m not going to pretend that’s some minor clerical thing. The incumbent, Dan S. Sullivan, has held the seat since 2015, and the ballot lists him as a registered Republican and as the incumbent. Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. filed in May, and in June, Division of Elections Director Carol Beecher tried to take him off the ballot. In a letter quoted in a later federal court order, she concluded his declaration “was not filed in order to declare an actual good faith candidacy,” but “with a purpose to confuse or mislead.” A state court put him back on, and Alaska’s Supreme Court let that stand, CNBC reported.
Then the Justice Department sued to delay certification if Sullivan lost and those votes would have changed the result, and U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason dismissed the case on Nov. 1, two days before the election. She found the government lacked standing and had no workable way to investigate those ballots without breaking ballot secrecy. She didn’t decide whether a decoy scheme took place. The department appealed to the Ninth Circuit.
The week before the election, The New York Times reported that Democratic operatives with links to the Peltola campaign had tried to recruit “spoiler” candidates, including Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. Peltola has denied any involvement, and Sullivan Jr. has denied any link to her campaign, and the BBC has said it has not independently verified the Times reporting. Recruiting a candidate to split a vote is generally legal, and I still wouldn’t call it decent.
President Trump has called Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. “the fake Dan Sullivan.” On Nov. 5 he wrote that “the vote totals for the Fake Dan Sullivan, plus the other ‘slug’ that the Dems put on the Ballot, should be immediately given to the REAL Dan Sullivan, and the Election is over – He easily wins.” On Monday he posted a clip of Bill O’Reilly saying the “Democratic Party in Alaska cheated.”
I’ve heard him on this, and I’m not going to just wave it off, so let’s add the votes the way he said to add them. Daniel J. Sullivan Jr.’s 4,684 plus the senator’s 130,162 comes out to 134,846, and Peltola is still ahead by 6,791. Throw in Heikes too, as the president’s “other slug” line asked, and you get 140,866, which on the current unofficial count still leaves her up by 771. That’s a small enough gap that the remaining mail could still move it, and I’m not going to tell you it couldn’t, but those 4,684 votes are not what put her more than 11,000 ahead to begin with.
That said, I do think some Republican voters meant to vote for Sen. Dan S. Sullivan and marked Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. by mistake. That’s what Division of Elections Director Carol Beecher was worried about when she tried to keep him off the ballot, the “confuse or mislead” problem. On the ballot, “Sullivan, Daniel J. Jr.” is listed first, with no party next to his name, and under him is “Sullivan, Dan S. (Registered Republican) Incumbent.” Alaska’s News Source talked to voters in Anchorage about that layout, and one of them said older people might just skip to the first name, and another said the same name “can confuse me.” After he voted, an Anchorage man told NewsNation he “definitely intended to vote for the real Dan Sullivan” and didn’t remember seeing the second one, and that there was a “slight possibility” he’d marked the wrong Sullivan. I’m not going to stand here and tell you that never happened.
I can’t tell you how many of the 4,684 were honest mistakes, and I won’t pretend I can. BBC Verify went through the second choices of the people who ranked Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. first, and thirty-eight percent left no valid second choice, and the BBC itself said we do not know how many of those voters may have thought they had already voted for Sen. Dan S. Sullivan and then not ranked anybody else. If that’s what happened, those ballots won’t move to the senator in a ranked-choice count either; they just stop. Fifteen percent did rank the Republican senator second. Twenty-nine percent ranked Peltola second, nearly twice as many, so you can’t scoop up all 4,684 and call them Republican votes that got stolen. The ceiling is 4,684, and that cannot erase an 11,475-vote lead by itself. It still matters at the edges. Peltola is only 52 votes short of a first-round majority, so the leftover mail may decide whether this even goes to a ranked-choice count, and in a closer race 4,684 votes could flip a seat. The confusion is real, and it likely cost Sullivan some votes, and it’s a mess states ought to fix so a name game like this can’t be run again. It isn’t the whole reason he’s behind.
I don’t like ranked-choice voting, and I especially don’t like a system that leaves the last Senate seat in America uncalled two weeks after the election, because it’s slow, and because a ballot with two men named Sullivan on it is an invitation to confusion, which is why Beecher tried to stop it. States should tighten the rules on how names appear instead of waiting for a close race to do it, and if Democratic operatives recruited a same-name candidate, I want them named and shamed, even if the tactic was legal. I also can’t look at the state’s own numbers, with or without the other Sullivan’s votes, and tell people this seat was stolen.
If she holds on, she will be the 56th Democratic senator, and Republicans will have lost a Senate seat they have held since 2015. I was hoping this midterm wasn’t going to be this bad, and it is. Face it, count every legal ballot, let them certify the result, and then fix the ballot so this name game can’t be run again. Treating a real confusion problem as if it were a stolen election, when the arithmetic still doesn’t close the gap, doesn’t get the seat back.
So I’ll ask you the question. Is this an “other Dan Sullivan” steal, or is Mary Peltola winning it on the votes they’ve already counted? Tell me I’m wrong, and tell me why. Watch The Ryan Samuels Show live Monday through Friday at 9 PM ET.
Ryan Samuels hosts The Ryan Samuels Show, a conservative podcast and political commentary show live Monday through Friday at 9 PM ET.
Listen to The Ryan Samuels Show:
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@RyanFSamuels
Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-ryan-samuels-show/id1652595335
Spotify: The Ryan Samuels Show on Spotify
Rumble: https://rumble.com/c/TheRyanSamuelsShow
Photo: Leah Herman, House Creative Services / Public domain (Wikimedia Commons)






