The Ryan Samuels Show

Monday–Friday at 9 PM ETMon–Fri 9 PM ET LIVE

The Ryan Samuels Show goes live weeknights at 9 PM ET.

Watch Live

Michigan Judge’s Ruling on 2020 Fake Electors: A Victory

Michigan Judge’s Ruling on 2020 Fake Electors: A Victory

On September 9, 2025, Michigan Judge Kristen D. Simmons dismissed charges against 15 people accused of serving as 2020 ‘fake electors’ for Donald Trump.

By Ryan F. Samuels, Host of The Ryan Samuels Show

Lansing, Michigan – On September 9, 2025, a Michigan judge delivered a landmark decision, dismissing criminal charges against 15 brave patriots accused of acting as “fake electors” for President Donald Trump in the 2020 election. District Court Judge Kristen D. Simmons’ ruling is a resounding victory for free speech and a bold step toward exposing the deep-seated corruption that marred the 2020 presidential election. On The Ryan Samuels Show, we’re celebrating this triumph of justice and diving into its implications for truth and accountability. Visit ryanfsamuels.com for the full story.

A Courageous Stand for Constitutional Rights

In December 2020, 15 Michigan Republicans, including prominent figures like former Michigan GOP Co-Chair Meshawn Maddock, met at the state’s GOP headquarters to sign a document asserting they were Michigan’s “duly elected and qualified electors” for Trump. This action came amidst widespread concerns about irregularities in the 2020 election, where Joe Biden was declared the winner by a margin of nearly 155,000 votes. These patriots, acting on their constitutional right to seek redress, aimed to preserve Trump’s legal challenges and ensure their voices were heard.

Judge Simmons, in a powerful ruling, declared there was insufficient evidence to prove the defendants acted with criminal intent. “This is a fraud case, and we have to prove intent,” she stated. “I believe they were executing their constitutional right to seek redress.” Her decision dismantles the narrative pushed by Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel, a Democrat, who charged the group with eight counts of forgery and conspiracy, each carrying a potential 14-year prison sentence. Simmons’ dismissal exposes these charges as a politically motivated attempt to silence dissent and punish those questioning the 2020 election’s integrity.

Free Speech Under Fire

The prosecution of these electors was a blatant attack on free speech, designed to intimidate Americans who dare challenge the establishment’s version of events. The 2020 election was riddled with controversies—unexplained vote spikes, unsecured ballot drop boxes, and allegations of voter fraud that were never fully investigated. The Michigan electors, acting on advice from Trump campaign lawyers, sought to highlight these issues by submitting an alternate slate of electors, a move rooted in their First Amendment rights to petition the government.

On The Ryan Samuels Show, we’ve long argued that questioning election integrity is not a crime—it’s a cornerstone of democracy. Judge Simmons’ ruling validates this principle, affirming that citizens have the right to challenge electoral processes without fear of prosecution. The dismissal sends a clear message: the government cannot criminalize free speech to protect a flawed narrative.

Shedding Light on 2020 Election Corruption

This ruling also casts a spotlight on the murky underbelly of the 2020 election. The electors’ actions were part of a broader effort to address concerns about fraud and irregularities, which were dismissed or ignored by courts and media at the time. A 2021 GOP-led Michigan Senate investigation confirmed Biden’s win but failed to thoroughly probe allegations of misconduct, leaving many questions unanswered. The fake elector strategy, while controversial, was an attempt to force Congress to scrutinize these issues during the January 6, 2021, electoral vote count—a process disrupted by the Capitol unrest.

The Michigan case exposes a troubling double standard. While Democrat-led prosecutors targeted Trump supporters, higher-profile figures like Rudy Giuliani and Kenneth Chesebro face charges elsewhere, suggesting a selective witch hunt. As I’ve said on The Ryan Samuels Show, the establishment wants to bury the 2020 election’s flaws, but rulings like this keep the truth alive.

A Victory for Truth and Accountability

The dismissal of charges against the Michigan electors is a triumph for every American who values free speech and demands transparency in our elections. Supporters outside the courtroom cheered, with defendants embracing loved ones, one tearfully exclaiming, “We did it.” This victory isn’t just for the 15 accused—it’s for millions who believe the 2020 election was mishandled and deserve answers.

However, the fight isn’t over. Similar cases in Nevada, Georgia, Wisconsin, and Arizona face setbacks, indicating a growing judicial skepticism of politically charged prosecutions. On The Ryan Samuels Show, we’ll continue to expose efforts to suppress election truth-tellers and hold corrupt officials accountable.

Why This Matters for The Ryan Samuels Show Audience

Judge Simmons’ ruling is a beacon of hope in a time when free speech and election integrity are under siege. It’s a reminder that courageously questioning the system can lead to justice. For our audience, this is a call to stay vigilant, demand accountability, and reject attempts to silence dissent. Tune in to The Ryan Samuels Show at ryanfsamuels.com for fearless analysis of this historic win, updates on election integrity battles, and the truth about America’s future.

Sources: Politico, CBS News, ABC News, MPR News, CNBC, The Hill, Bloomberg Law, MSN

Filed under:

Get Ryan’s Columns in Your Inbox

Sign up for free and get every new column from The Ryan Samuels Show delivered to your inbox.