Pat Catalano is a Chicago-area musician and the host of The Beard Speaks Podcast, a show he started during the COVID years to have, as he put it, raw, real conversations. He told Ryan that, episode after episode, those conversations kept coming back to the same place. “People I talked to, like musicians, authors, motivational speakers, people from all walks of life, really started to understand that this family court issue touches everyone,” he said (12:56). He is also involved with The Ministry For Family Integrity.
He was on The Ryan Samuels Show Friday night (Nov. 20) for Family Court Fridays, live at 9 p.m. ET. The case he came to talk about is Catalano v. Accardo, No. 2020 D 080048, in the Circuit Court of Cook County. In an April 8, 2021, order, Judge William Stewart Boyd wrote that Catalano “is not to take the minor child to Church until further order by this Court.”

From a split to a courtroom
Catalano and the child’s mother were never married. He told Ryan he was diagnosed with Hodgkin’s lymphoma in 2015, that the relationship ended around 2018, and that for a couple of years after that he could see his daughter whenever he wanted. That changed, he said, after he began seeing the woman who is now his wife, around the end of 2019 and the beginning of 2020. He said the child’s mother began telling him the new relationship was unsafe, and that his time was cut to a few hours in a car.
“I went from being able to see my daughter whenever I wanted to two or three hours in my car because I couldn’t take her to my house or she would call the police,” he said (18:16). “We’re sitting in the car eating pizza on a Thursday night for a couple of hours, and that’s all I got” (18:44). He said he hired a lawyer and went to court in the fall of 2020.
The church order
Catalano told Ryan that he and his daughter used to go to church together, and that he started going in the first place because of her, after his cancer treatment. “I was blown away because I started going to that church because of my daughter,” he said (42:40).
The April 8, 2021, order is signed by Judge Boyd. It also moved Catalano’s Sunday parenting time to 11:30 a.m. through 9 p.m. The order does not say who asked for the church restriction, or why. Nothing in the court papers Catalano provided for the show shows a later order lifting it.
What the guardian ad litem wrote
Brian E. Alexander was appointed guardian ad litem on Feb. 16, 2021, on the mother’s motion. Ryan told viewers he had emailed Alexander for comment. Alexander wrote that Ryan was free to comment, but that “client confidentiality (the minor’s) preclude me from discussing any portion of the matter in a public forum.”
Catalano’s account of his first call with Alexander is his account. He told Ryan that after he explained the timeline, Alexander said the problem was something else, and that Alexander called him a homophobe, a racist and a transphobe. “This was over the phone,” Catalano said (21:45).
Alexander’s own written report, which is undated but notes that a 604 evaluation had been ordered and was not yet finished, contains a line Ryan read on the air. “No allegation of evidence has been presented that in any way establishes that Father is a danger to the physical health or safety of the minor.” In the same report, Alexander recommended against expanding Catalano’s time until a period of family therapy, writing that forcing more time than the child wanted “may lead to irreparable psychological harm.”
Catalano told Ryan that Alexander never came to his home. “Never. Never once. He never showed up to my home,” he said (45:04).
Fees, and a lawsuit he says he filed
The Feb. 16 appointment form leaves the paid-fee box unchecked, and the hourly rate is marked “n/a.” Catalano told Ryan the appointment was pro bono. Seven weeks later, the same April 8 order required each party to pay Alexander $1,250 in temporary fees. On Oct. 31, 2022, according to a motion later filed by Catalano’s counsel, Alexander sought interim fees. The motion describes that request as $9,155 and asks the court to dismiss it as barred by the original appointment.
“He was appointed pro bono,” Catalano said (49:17). “So now you’re paying someone to tear apart your family” (49:31).
He told Ryan he has filed a lawsuit against Alexander. “You have immunity, but you only have immunity if you work within the scope of your appointment as a GAL,” he said (51:26). He alleges Alexander stepped outside that scope. The documents he provided for the show do not include that complaint, and that filing was not independently confirmed. “All I said was, I wanna be a dad. I just wanna be in my daughter’s life. That’s it” (52:08).
The 604 evaluation
At Catalano’s request, Dr. Kerry Smith was appointed in September 2021 to perform a 604.10(b) custody evaluation. Her report, dated July 21, 2022, recommended no overnight parenting time for Catalano and that the mother have final decision-making authority on medical and educational issues.
Catalano told Ryan they hired Smith, that she came to his house once, and that what came back was not what he expected. In his view, the evaluation used his religion and his politics against him. “They used my religion against me, my political beliefs against me, and basically turned it into the silver bullet to keep away my daughter,” he said (58:55). He told Ryan he has not seen his daughter in more than a year.
The Ministry For Family Integrity
Catalano told Ryan he no longer believes family-court reform will fix what he went through. “I’m working with a new organization called the Ministry for Family Integrity,” he said (1:02:37). The group’s site describes its mission as protecting and restoring parent-child relationships. Catalano’s account of the work is more direct: a “Show Me the Law” campaign, and federal lawsuits aimed at the states. “We need to abolish the family courts and restructure something that helps families,” he said (1:03:30).
“And right now, my mission is to help the kids and parents that are going through this through my podcast, The Beard Speaks,” he said (1:05:06). For parents looking for help, he pointed to the ministry and to his show. “If you’re going through this pain, speak up,” he said. “Just don’t stay silent” (1:07:32).
About Pat Catalano
Pat Catalano is a Chicago-area musician and the host of The Beard Speaks Podcast, which can be found at thebeardspeakspodcast.com. He is involved with The Ministry For Family Integrity. His album Paper Crowns, released with The Pat Catalano Project, is available on elasticStage.
Meet more of Ryan’s guests on the Guests page.






